Tedeschi's Italian Eatery

The hamburger was excellent. The patty was flavorful, well seasoned, obviously handmade, and the french fries were excellent. We also ordered the Chicago style pepperoni pizza. The crust had just the right amount of crunch on the bottom with a little bit of chewiness. The sauce had excellent flavor and presence without being overwhelming. The tiramisu is very well done. Good balance. Overall an excellent experience.

Cute place to stop that’s open later than most places. Waitress was super nice and gave great recommendations stating everything is fresh and mainly done in house which was a huge selling point. Based off previous reviews I got the pizza rolls and the previous reviews and a beef, mushroom and cheese sandwich. Pizza rolls 10/10 would definitely order again The sandwich… eh 3/10. Meat was VERY salty, canned mushrooms. Anywhere that uses canned mushrooms is huge red flag especially after how it was explained everything is fresh and homemade. Definitely open to trying other stuff on the menu but just avoid the beef and mushrooms.

We were seated right away and our server was kind, knowledgeable, and attentive. However it took almost 40 min for two sandwiches and they were not exceptionally busy. While other people who were seated after us received entrees, we continued to wait for our sandwiches which was a bit frustrating. Trying to maintain patience our waiter continued running around getting orders serving and getting drinks for people we didn’t want to bother him waiting to grab our card for checkout so we left our tip at the table and proceeded to the register where a girl was doing nothing but leaning on the counter. We tried handing over our receipt to pay and she inquired who are server was that we should return to our table to wait… we kindly inquired can’t we just pay here? No he has a machine that will take it at your table. So once again we waited for our server to come take our credit payment which easily could have been taken at the register. I find it unfair for a server to be running around and expected to do everything from start to finish. Why payments cannot be taken at the register on your way out the door like it used to seems to be an inconvenience for most involved. I’m a very patient person and truly feel for the waiters who are running around like crazy and the person standing at the register doing nothing just tells the customers to go back to their table. Food was great and server was great!

I very rarely give a pizza restaurant 10stars. I’m Italian and grew up eating high quality ingredients. This crew nailed it. My Mom and Dad and I stopped in on our way back from Utica. We ordered a large half mushroom half spinach Chicago style pizza. Everything was perfect. The crust, sauce and toppings are fresh and neatly placed evenly. Temperature and cooking time is on point. The server was just as great as the pizza. Highly recommend stopping of the 81 to eat here. If you do, then you don’t need to stop in Binghamton.